It turns out that one of the Senior officers saw it and referred my post to someone who could help me!
And after going back and forth for 2 more emails:
Would you believe that at this moment - I have just picked up my car from being fixed at the Body Shop!?! GEICO really came through and they were SOOO nice and amazing through this whole process... At 1st I was frustrated with the whole situation, but they really did an amazing job to help me out!
And here are some pictures of what my car looks like after they fixed it a 3rd and hopefully the last time!
THANKS AGAIN GEICO